beg the question

beg the question
1) лог. приводить в качестве аргумента положение, которое само нуждается в доказательстве, подменить посылку желательным для себя выводом (логическая ошибка, связанная с нарушением закона достаточного основания)

But nothing was more calculated to annoy Halidome than to tell him he was "begging the question", for he prided himself on being strong in logic. (J. Galsworthy, ‘The Island Pharisees’, part I, ch. V) — Ничто не могло так раздосадовать Халидома, как утверждение, что он начинает с желательного для него вывода, а не с доказательства, так как он гордился тем, что был силен в логике.

2) голословно утверждать (что-л.), приводить в качестве аргумента спорное положение; оставлять под вопросом

And he went up to his bed. If there was point in anything, it was in perpetuation of oneself, though, of course, that begged the question. (J. Galsworthy, ‘The White Monkey’, part I, ch. XII) — И Сомс пошел спать. Если и был в чем-нибудь смысл, то только в продолжении своего рода, хотя и это еще вопрос.

But it seems to me you're begging the question. you're assuming that all abnormal conduct is a symptom of mental illness. (M. West, ‘Daughter of Silence’, ch. III) — Ваше утверждение, что любое ненормальное поведение - признак душевного заболевания, представляется мне весьма спорным.

3) уклоняться от предмета спора, от сути дела, избегать трудностей

I am not going tonight to beg the question of what sexual reform means. (B. Shaw, ‘Platform and Pulpit’, ‘The Need for Expert Opinion in Sexual Reform’) — Сегодня я не собираюсь уклоняться от обсуждения вопроса о сущности реформы в области секса.


Большой англо-русский фразеологический словарь. - М.: «Русский язык-Медиа».. 2006.

Игры ⚽ Нужно решить контрольную?

Полезное


Смотреть что такое "beg the question" в других словарях:

  • beg the question — means, strictly speaking, to question an unproved assumption that is used as the basis for an argument. For example, to ask ‘why do you listen to that rubbish?’ begs the question when the quality of the music is the point at issue. In general use …   Modern English usage

  • beg the question — In philosophy to beg the question is to assume something to be true that has not yet been proved. I have seen the idiom also to mean that a question is crying out to be asked …   The small dictionary of idiomes

  • beg the question — ► beg the question 1) (of a fact or action) invite a question or point that has not been dealt with. 2) assume the truth of a proposition without arguing it. Main Entry: ↑beg …   English terms dictionary

  • beg the question — 1. To avoid giving an answer 2. To assume that the thing to be proved is already true in one of the premises, or in part of the proof (logic) 3. To raise an issue for debate (non standard) • • • Main Entry: ↑beg …   Useful english dictionary

  • Beg the Question — is a graphic novel by Bob Fingerman. It chronicles the trials and tribulations of Rob, a squeamish freelance cartoonist/pornographer, and Sylvia, a beauty salon manager with loftier aspirations, with a supporting cast featuring Jack, an unhappily …   Wikipedia

  • beg the question — index prevaricate Burton s Legal Thesaurus. William C. Burton. 2006 …   Law dictionary

  • beg the question —    In philosophy to beg the question is to assume something to be true that has not yet been proved. I have seen the idiom also to mean that a question is crying out to be asked.   (Dorking School Dictionary) …   English Idioms & idiomatic expressions

  • beg the question — verb a) To engage in the logical fallacy of begging the question (petitio principii). The objection is that the argument begs the question, meaning that the premise, that God has all the virtues, assumes the conclusion, that God is benevolent. b) …   Wiktionary

  • beg the question — 1. if a statement or situation begs the question, it causes you to ask a particular question. It s all very well talking about extra staff but it rather begs the question of how we re going to pay for them. 2. if something that someone says begs… …   New idioms dictionary

  • beg the question — 1) to make you want to know the answer to a particular question If she got caught stealing money and she s still here, it begs the question: What would she have to do to get fired? 2) formal to discuss a problem, issue, or fact as if it… …   English dictionary

  • beg the question — {v. phr.}, {literary} To accept as true something that is still being argued about, before it is proved true; avoid or not answer a question or problem. * /The girls asked Miss Smith if they should wear formal dresses to the party; Miss Smith… …   Dictionary of American idioms


Поделиться ссылкой на выделенное

Прямая ссылка:
Нажмите правой клавишей мыши и выберите «Копировать ссылку»